Racism or curiosity? Where are you from?

Anyone with an accent, dark skin, or Asian features knows it. One of the most common questions we get asked is, “Where are you from?” Usually, it comes right after you exchange names but sometimes, if you’re a New York City cabbie for instance, that question may get asked even if your questioner hasn’t seen your face.

Humans are curious creatures, and most of the time those asking –myself included—are looking for a way to connect. When people find that you’re from their home town or city, they might ask you what school you went to. Or they might mention an acquaintance who lives in your town, works in your company or attends the same church. We do this all the time.

But what happens when people who were born in this country, or those who are second or third generation American, continue to be asked,

“Where are you from?” And when they answer,
“Newark, New Jersey,” they still get,
“No, really, where are you from?”
“Newark, New Jersey.”
“But where are your parents from?”
“Newark, New Jersey.”

Usually, this line of questioning doesn’t stop until you answer what they really want to know, “My great grand parents came from Guadalajara, Mexico.”

Although the intention of the person asking the question may be good (they may be interested in finding out more about you), the impact is often what we call a microaggression, a verbal or non-verbal act that is indirect and often invisible, through which people express prejudices in a covert way.

In this case, it is as if you are denying this person’s identity as an American. As if their identity is forever tied to that of their remote ancestors, something we don’t do with white, Anglo Saxon people. As a matter of fact, this question means something entirely different to a white person. It means what city or town were you born in. And if you kept on asking, “No, really, where are you from?” They’d look at you as if you were crazy or deaf.

Putting up with these kinds of microaggressions on a daily basis hurts, and inevitably, it creates resentment. Think of comments such as, “No offense but Hispanics are all loud. And don’t get me wrong, my best friend is Hispanic,” as if that qualified the speaker to generalize about a whole group. Or the surprised observation about an African American who speaks well, “She’s so articulate,” which in a subtle way implies most blacks are not. Or the comment, “When I look at you, I don’t see color. You are different than other Latinos (or Blacks),” denying that person’s dark skin which is part of their identity.

The truth is that there’s a microaggression in each one of these comments, although most likely those making them think they are being complimentary. The problem here is the incongruence between intention and impact.

I’m not pointing fingers. No one group owns the patent on microaggressions. At one time or another, most of us have said or done something that made someone different from us feel uncomfortable. Most of it comes from ignorance of what triggers these feelings in others. A lot of it is lack of cultural capital.

The best way to minimize these hurtful acts is to be aware of your intention and carefully imagine the impact that your words or behavior have on someone with a different background.

And if you really are curious about where your cabbie is from, maybe you could start by sharing something about yourself.

“Hey, I’m Peter Van Der Haas, and my parents are from Holland. What’s your heritage?” or “What’s your ancestry?” That may go a long way toward your cabbie taking the shortest route to your destination.

Mariela Dabbah’s new book Poder de Mujer was just released by Penguin.

This Op Ed appeared on Fox News Latino in March, 2012

Tags: , , ,

4 Responses to “Racism or curiosity? Where are you from?”

  1. Susan says:

    My in-laws immigrated to the US from Switzerland in the 1950s. They’re in their 80s now and they STILL get asked “where are you from?” every time they open their mouths. Since they have lived here over 2/3 of their lives and are US citizens, they always answer “Rochester, NY” and they get the “No, where are you REALLY from?” every time!

  2. how to get whiter skin says:

    Dear Roger, we may never know his name, nor when the actual city of Hamlin was, but have no doubt, that story was never “made up”, and while it no doubt has embellishments to it, such a straight forward story, with such an accurate statement of the nature of people must always be assumed to have been true exactly, at one time. I was told as a child, most of the Bible is “allegory or hypothetical” and all sorts of excuses why the stories we receive from ancient history are just made up stories, but all the evidence of archeology throughout my life has shown that to be a foolish perspective, and assuming ancient stories were based in fact is always a more accurate assumption. There are literally dozens of cities being excavated today solely because a few dedicated believers refused to accept the notion which was common in my childhood, that all the old stories were fairy tales, and using the Bible, and now other ancient texts, every single city looked for has been discovered, and a great many whose existence was lost with the loss of great libraries, have been found because of references in the discovered cities, further opening our past. The making of such stories as “fables” has always been used by the left, for millennia, to hide the truth of man’s proclivities, and make people figure out about evil late, rather than in their youth.Sincerely,John McClainVanceboro, NC

  3. Miriam Fabiancic says:

    I am an Argentine with two children born in the U.S.; I was appalled the other day when I was introduced to a higher-ranking officer at a U.S. Embassy in Latin America, and after I mentioned that my children were American, this person took a step back and said “Impossible!” I said, “oh yes, they are American because they were born in America!” There’s ignorance and aggression everywhere, and some times it’s not in such covert ways as Mariela describes here. I also believe all of us who are “different” because of our ancestry, accents, or hairstyles know better and should not take offense–but sometimes it takes two deep breaths and a lot of patience to stay above the situation, ignore the comment and move on. Thank you, Mariela for this wonderful article.

  4. Miriam Fabiancic says:

    I am an Argentine with two children born in the U.S.; I was appalled the other day when I was introduced to a higher-ranking officer at a U.S. Embassy in Latin America, and after I mentioned that my children were American, this person took a step back and said \"Impossible!\" I said, \"oh yes, they are American because they were born in America!\" There\’s ignorance and aggression everywhere, and some times it\’s not in such covert ways as Mariela describes here. I also believe all of us who are \"different\" because of our ancestry, accents, or hairstyles know better and should not take offense–but sometimes it takes two deep breaths and a lot of patience to stay above the situation, ignore the comment and move on. Thank you, Mariela for this wonderful article.

Leave a Reply

Security Code: